Enrollment vs Spending Growth by State
Does a state's Medicare physician spending rise simply because it has more Medicare beneficiaries? This page compares, state by state, growth in Medicare physician/supplier payments (CMS Medicare Physician & Other Practitioners PUF) with growth in Medicare enrollment (CMS Medicare Monthly Enrollment). States where spending outpaces enrollment are leads for further review — not findings of improper billing. Public aggregates only (no PHI).
Which beneficiaries? The Physician PUF covers Part B fee-for-service (Original Medicare) physician/supplier claims only — Medicare Advantage claims are not in it. So the primary denominator here is Part B Original Medicare (FFS) enrollment; total Medicare enrollment (including Medicare Advantage) is shown for comparison. Enrollment figures are CMS annual averages of monthly counts.
Attribution: CMS Medicare Physician & Other Practitioners — by Provider and Service (2022–2024); CMS Medicare Monthly Enrollment (data.cms.gov).
Pearson r — FFS Part B enrollment vs spend growth
Pearson r — total enrollment vs spend growth
Spend growth (50 states + DC)
FFS Part B enrollment growth
In plain language: across the 50 states and DC, the correlation between FFS Part B enrollment growth and physician spending growth for 2022→2024 is r = 0.77 ( strong positive ; rank correlation 0.75 ). Using total Medicare enrollment instead, r = 0.50 ( strong positive ). Pooled across these jurisdictions, physician spending changed 9.3% while FFS Part B enrollment changed -5.6% (enrollment fell in 50 of 51 as beneficiaries shifted to Medicare Advantage). A positive r means states that kept more FFS enrollees tended to see faster spending growth; the dashed line shows where spending would track enrollment one-for-one — points above it are spending more per FFS beneficiary than in the base year.
Enrollment growth vs spending growth, by state
Each dot is a state (50 states + DC). CA and MN are highlighted and labeled. Points above the dashed diagonal grew spending faster than enrollment.
California & Minnesota
States ranked by growth gap
Gap = spending growth minus FFS Part B enrollment growth (shown in percentage points). Sorted largest first for the selected period.
Correlation summary (all periods)
How to read this — caveats
| Item | Detail |
|---|---|
| Partly mechanical | FFS physician spending can only come from FFS enrollees, so the shift to Medicare Advantage pulls both measures down together. A positive r is expected for that reason alone; the gap (spending growth above enrollment growth) is the more informative lead. |
| Correlation ≠ causation | A weak or strong r says nothing on its own about why spending moved. Fee-schedule updates, coding changes, practice consolidation, population aging, and shifts between FFS and Medicare Advantage all play a role. |
| Spending scope | Physician PUF = Part B fee-for-service physician/supplier payments only (no Medicare Advantage, hospital inpatient, or Part D). Payment = Avg_Mdcr_Pymt_Amt × Tot_Srvcs, summed. |
| Enrollment basis | Primary: Part B Original Medicare (FFS) enrollees — matches the PUF's FFS scope. Total Medicare (incl. Medicare Advantage) shown for comparison. CMS annual figure = average of monthly counts. |
| Geography mismatch | PUF spending is assigned to the rendering provider's state; enrollment counts beneficiaries by residence. Cross-border care (e.g. DC, border metros) can distort a single state. |
| Suppression | The PUF omits provider×service rows with fewer than 11 beneficiaries, so small totals are slightly understated. |
| Framing | A large gap is a lead for further review, never an accusation against any state, provider, or beneficiary. |